Client Success | Cottingham & Butler

Client Impact Stories

Delivering Better Outcomes Every Day

Driving Results That Matter

At Cottingham & Butler, we believe every challenge has a solution. Explore how we partner with clients to create breakthrough solutions that deliver meaningful, measurable impact.

EMPLOYEE BENEFITS

TRANSPORTATION

PROPERTY & CASUALTY

Employee Benefits

$200,000+ in Savings Through Non-Medical Benefits Overhaul

Through strategic analysis, this transformation delivered $2.5M in total savings spanning pharmacy, stop-loss, and more.

Medicare Part D Disclosures due by March 1, 2025 for Calendar Year Plans

Health plans must report Medicare drug coverage status to CMS by March 1, 2025.

BenefitWave Discovers Insights on What Employees Value Most

BenefitWave finds crucial insights into what employees truly value when it comes to their benefits.

2 3 4 5

Transportation

How Strategic Insurance Planning Saved a Small Fleet Missouri Trucking Company $16,000 after a Catastrophic Fire

A devastating truck fire led two insurance experts to turn crisis into savings, securing a $16,488 premium reduction.

Trucking Company Saved Nearly $930,000 During Their First Year with Cottingham & Butler

Success in the trucking industry requires more than just insurance coverage – it demands a partner who understands the unique challenges...

Case Study Property Casualty

Property & Casualty

Claims Advocacy Expertise Secured a $124K+ Settlement Increase Through Water Damage Reclassification

Discover how strategic claims advocacy turned an initial water damage assessment into major additional coverage for proper remediation.

25% Premium Reduction for Agricultural Design-Build General Contractor

Our prospective client is an agricultural design-build general contractor who had been with their broker for 20+ years.

Achieving a 52% Rate Reduction and $300k Premium Savings through Comprehensive Property Program Restructuring

Discover how Cottingham & Butler achieved a 52% rate reduction and $300k premium savings through strategic property program restructuring.

“Our collaboration with Cottingham & Butler has been transformative.”

Rihm Kenworth